A.M. Best Financial Strength Ratings
Health Insurance Financial Ratings
In evaluating health plans, there's no more critical consideration than the insurance company's financial strength. AM Best is the most recognized insurance company rating service.
The following ratings are for well-known health insurance companies marketing individual health insurance products in Illinois and in Indiana. Each insurance company name links to it's updated AM Best rating page.
This listing was last revised April 10, 2010:
- Aetna Health: A (Excellent)
- American Community Mutual: D (Poor) - Court Ordered Rehabilitation
- American Family Life Insurance: A (Excellent)
- American Medical Security: A- (Excellent)
- Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield: A (Excellent)
- Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Illinois (HCSC): A+ (Superior)
- Celtic Insurance Company: B++ (Good)
- Central Reserve Life: B++ (Good)
- Companion Life: A+ (Superior)
- Conseco Life Insurance Company: B (Fair)
- Consumers Life Insurance: Insufficient data
- Continental General: B++ (Good)
- Golden Rule / United HealthCare: A (Excellent)
- Guarantee Trust Life: B+ (Good)
- Humana : A- (Excellent)
- John Alden: A- (Excellent)
- Mega Life & Health: B++ (Good)
- Physicians Health Plan of Northern Indiana: B+ (Good)
- Time Insurance Company: A- (Excellent)
- United Security Life: C+ (Marginal)
